Five Million Voices

Should the mandatory registration system for log traders and forestry advisers be disestablished and the fees and levies paid to it be refunded?

The bill repeals the mandatory registration system and associated requirements for log traders and forestry advisers introduced under 2020 legislation, and directs the Ministry for Primary Industries to refund fees and levies already paid and waive any due at commencement.

⚡ Taken under urgency

Parliament advanced this bill under urgency (committee of whole house, first reading, second reading, third reading) — moving it through faster than usual, with less time than normal for public submissions.

MPs’ arguments for and against the bill

Why support it
  • Supporters argued the mandatory registration system added compliance costs without delivering meaningful improvements, and that removing it lets businesses keep more money and focus on operating.
  • Supporters said a voluntary registration system run by the New Zealand Institute of Forestry can maintain professional standards without regulation.
  • Supporters contended that regulations should be reassessed over time and changed when they are found not to be achieving their intended outcomes, as they said this scheme had not.
Why oppose it
  • Opponents argued the registration scheme was introduced to give landowners access to impartial, qualified advice and to guard against operators who had previously taken advantage of inexperienced owners.
  • Opponents said the scheme had only been in place for a few years and should be given more time, noting that under the prior voluntary system only 10 to 12 percent of advisers registered.
  • Opponents objected that the repeal was being progressed under urgency without a select committee process or consultation with Māori land owners and the sector.

These are claims MPs made in Parliament’s debate — not verified facts.

Full bill summary & link to official bill page

This bill repeals a registration scheme for log traders and forestry advisers that was added to the Forests Act 1949 by an amendment in 2020. Under that scheme, businesses that buy and sell logs, and people who give professional forestry advice, are required to register with a government registrar and meet obligations intended to improve the reliability and integrity of the log supply chain. The bill removes that mandatory registration and the associated rules, so that operating as a log trader or forestry adviser would no longer require being on an official register. The government's view is that the scheme has not delivered worthwhile results and imposes compliance costs and paperwork on forestry businesses without a matching benefit. It affects log traders, forestry consultants and advisers, forest owners and growers, and the wider timber and wood-processing sector, particularly smaller operators for whom the registration burden weighs most heavily.

The scheme being repealed was championed by the previous government's forestry minister as a way to build confidence in log supply and the quality of forestry advice. The current government argues the regime failed to achieve those aims and prefers a voluntary approach, such as registration through the New Zealand Institute of Forestry, which it considers more effective and less costly. Supporters of repeal, including forest-grower groups, welcome the removal of what they see as unnecessary red tape and expense during a difficult period for the industry. Opponents argue the registration system was meant to provide better information about log supply, professional standards and continuity, and that scrapping it removes oversight and hard-won transparency from a sector important to exports and regional economies. The disagreement is essentially about whether formal regulation or a lighter voluntary model better serves the forestry supply chain.

See the Parliament.nz ↗ site for the full bill.

Oppose (No) Support (Yes)

Forests (Log Traders and Forestry Advisers Repeal) Amendment Bill · Third Reading, 25 Jun 2024
Parliament voted 102–17 — it passed.